Search
Close this search box.

Trump’s First Year Back: Carrot-and-Stick Tactics Thrust US Into Global Spotlight

Washington: One year after President Donald Trump returned to the White House, the US has once again moved to the center of global attention, driven by a volatile mix of threats, deal-making, and unpredictability that has reshaped Washington's relations with allies and adversaries alike, analysts say.

According to Anadolu Agency, Inderjeet Parmar, a professor of international politics at the University of London, stated that Trump has thrust America back into the global spotlight over the past year through his bombastic statements, outbursts, and policy decisions, including aggressive trade tariffs. While the White House frames Trump's approach as 'peace through strength,' critics argue it has unsettled allies, weakened trust in US commitments, and strained the rules-based international order.

Parmar noted that Trump's return to power, combined with moves such as new tariffs on Chinese imports and withdrawal from international climate agreements, has reignited debates over US hegemony and the nature of American leadership. This attention, analysts say, has come at a cost.

Roseanne McManus, a professor of political science at Pennsylvania State University, expressed that Trump certainly gained more attention for America, even compared to the typical high level of attention. Yet much of this attention is negative, making the US appear imperialistic, indifferent to democracy and international law, and unreliable as an ally. Parmar agreed that the spotlight has led to growing strains between Washington and its traditional allies, highlighting fractures in alliances, as seen in strained NATO relations and EU retaliatory measures. Trump's tariffs, aimed at 'America First,' have sparked global economic volatility, affecting supply chains from Asia to Latin America.

Experts describe Trump's foreign policy as a classic carrot-and-stick approach, pairing threats with incentives in rapid succession. Parmar remarked that this strategy is evident in dealings with nations like Ukraine, Russia, China, and recently Colombia, blending threats with overtures of friendship. Last year, Trump spoke positively about Russian President Vladimir Putin several times, telling reporters they had a 'very good relationship,' while also warning him of 'severe consequences' and more sanctions if Russia blocked a peace deal for Ukraine.

In Latin America, Trump has taken a comparable approach. Amid tensions with Colombia over migration and drug trafficking, he threatened border closures and economic pressure while offering cooperation and investment as incentives for compliance. McManus said Trump's deal-making instincts remain central to his strategy, showing eagerness for anything he can portray as a victory.

Analysts say Trump's unpredictability is not limited to rhetoric but is embedded in his policy agenda, which often shifts suddenly and without warning. McManus pointed to US missile strikes on Iranian nuclear sites last summer, ordered after Trump publicly suggested he would take more time to consider military action. David Andersen, a professor of US politics at Durham University, sees Trump's unpredictability as deliberate, emphasizing his focus on results and lack of constraints by facts, planning, or norms of behavior.

Parmar said that unpredictability and perceived irrationality in foreign relations can be viewed as a deliberate tactic rather than mere chaos - though it carries profound risks. As Trump enters the second year of his second term, analysts expect his foreign policy to remain confrontational and transactional, prioritizing deals over alliances.

For Andersen, whatever comes next is likely to be shocking and unprecedented, with Trump rewriting how the US works and what its priorities are. McManus suggested that Trump's increasing confidence from experience and surrounding advisers who are ideologically aligned have further emboldened him.