Search
Close this search box.

Western Media Narratives on Gaza and Iran Criticized for ‘Dehumanization’: Investigative Journalist Scahill

Istanbul: Western media coverage of Gaza and Iran is shaped by a 'dehumanizing' narrative that distorts conflict reporting, investigative journalist Jeremy Scahill said. 'The entire thing is about dehumanizing both Iran and the Palestinians. It's an inversion of reality,' Scahill, co-founder of Drop Site News, told Anadolu.

According to Anadolu Agency, Scahill stated that mainstream media is being used by governments as a political tool to justify their actions. 'In the post-9/11 world, the United States still was holding on to the idea that it was going to make an argument that this is legal, that there are hostile threats and terrorists in the world that must be confronted. With Donald Trump, they don't even pretend anymore.'

Scahill, author of "Blackwater: The Rise of the World's Most Powerful Mercenary Army," also condemned what he described as unprecedented violence against journalists in Gaza. He noted, 'We are right now in the midst of the single largest serial killer, mass murder campaign against journalists in human history. More than 300 Palestinian media workers have been killed, many of them intentionally.'

He rejected the framing of such deaths as wartime 'collateral damage,' calling them instead 'an actual serial killer campaign aimed at murdering journalists whose crime is being the eyes and ears of the world.' Scahill also criticized what he described as the silence of Western media organizations, saying it amounted to complicity.

'There's also in some ways a more devastating and dangerous category, and that is journalists who have been silent in the face of the killing of our colleagues. Most major Western news organizations have said absolutely nothing about the mass killing of our Palestinian journalist colleagues.'

Despite this, Scahill noted a positive development, highlighting that traditional media's dominance has been weakened. 'These huge media organizations, their monopoly on the dissemination of information has been shattered,' he said, adding that 'independent journalism is rising.'

Scahill pointed out the role of Palestinians in documenting their own plight. 'Palestinians, by filming the genocide of their own people, served as the eyes and ears of the world,' he said, adding that big media corporations no longer have 'the power to filter any of it.' He called Gaza 'the first live-stream genocide in history,' stressing that 'the perception of Israel and the broader Zionist project has never been in a greater crisis.'

Furthermore, Scahill warned against the growing criminalization of engaging with opposing perspectives. He defended the practice of interviewing members of Hamas, Hezbollah, and Iranian leaders as a core responsibility of journalism, arguing that it would be 'journalistic malpractice' not to speak to those framed as 'villains.'

He criticized media narratives that create a 'cartoonized version' of Palestinian resistance or portray Iran as being run solely by the Islamic Revolutionary Guard, stating that such depictions distort public understanding of conflicts. This framing, he argued, 'sets people up to be shocked' by real-world responses, including Iran's 'retaliatory strikes' after leadership assassinations.

Scahill emphasized the need for journalists to explore perspectives from 'the other side of the gun, the American gun, that is pointed at the rest of the world and interview the people that live on the other side of it.'

On the topic of Iran, he pointed out misrepresentations in Western narratives regarding Tehran's position in negotiations. 'In the case of Iran, you have Trump saying that the Iranians are begging him to make a deal, and yet at every turn it's the Iranians who are refusing to give up their sovereignty.'